How to create an irresistible lead magnet to attract new email subscribers

Guest Post by The Email Marketing Mum


Here’s some tough love … over 95% of visitors to your website won’t buy anything on their first visit.

Sorry, but I had to rip the band aid off.

Chances are they’re browsing, checking you out and doing a bit of research before committing to anything. The only way you’re going to gain their trust and build confidence is with time. Time you don’t have on their first visit, but time you can create by offering them a chance to join your mailing list.

Sounds so easy doesn’t it?  Their email address in exchange for … sale alerts or updates?

Hmmm…. there needs to be a better exchange of value here.

When we give up our email address we’re essentially inviting a person or brand into our personal online space. It’s not a decision we make lightly. Think about your own inbox. Have you curated it just the way you like it? Does it feel like a collection of all your favourite things, from bloggers to brands and people? It’s personal right?

So, as a brand how do you get ‘in’?

This is where creating an incentive comes in handy. Also known as a lead magnet. It’s an offer of perceived high value that makes someone want to part with their email address on the spot. Before getting into how to create your lead magnet, let’s look at what a lead magnet is not.

A lead magnet is not about promoting your business. Sorry, ripping off another band aid.

Sure, once you have someone’s email address sending relevant and timely emails about promotions is fine, but what value are you adding to this person’s life in order to get their email address in the first place?

So that’s done. Now, how do you go about creating your lead magnet? Whether you have a few ideas or none at all, here are 3 things you need to consider:

1. Will it add value to your ideal customer’s life? Knowing what type of lead magnet to offer begins with knowing your ideal customer or client inside out. Think about what their pain points are and how you could help solve them. If you’re unsure,
find out by polling your existing audience, posting questions to your social followers or in groups where you know your ideal customer likes to hang out.
Tip: It also doesn’t hurt to research what your competitors are doing for inspiration. Just sayin’.

2. Does it create an emotion? The only emotion you want your potential subscriber to feel is the excitement that they’re
getting something really valuable for free. Think about how your ideal customer would react to your offer. Is it a nice-to-have or a must-have?
Hint: It should be the second one.

3. Can you deliver a quality lead magnet? Just because someone is getting something for free doesn’t mean the quality should be any less than if they were paying for it. Think of it as a representation of your brand. It’s the thing that gets someone into your business so setting the tone just right is key.

Use this handy checklist to help create your lead magnet:

  • Is it something enticing that your ideal customer wants, or even better, needs?
  • Is it something that you could even charge $’s for, but won’t?
  • Does it solve a problem for your ideal customer?
  • Does it promise a ‘quick win’ to make their life easier, quicker?
  • Is it easy to understand? Will your ideal customer ‘get it’ easily enough?
  • Is it easy to access and can it be used straight away?

Jolly good! Now it’s time to brainstorm…

Download my 14-page free guide: 37 Lead Magnet Ideas To Grow Your Email List. Created for e-Commerce businesses, service-based businesses and bloggers. This guide will give you oodles of inspiration to create an irresistible lead magnet that your ideal customer is going to love. It’s designed to help you think outside of the box and create something truly unique to your

I hope you get inspired!

Share your lead magnet with me and let me know what you created for your business –

About Tamsin

Tamsin is a Sydney based email marketing specialist and mum to two. She can help on all things email marketing related from account audits to strategy and implementing any type of email campaign or automation. She’s a creative problem-solver who loves teaching others to get the best out of their key marketing channel.

Check out her website.

Creating a values-based content strategy

Creating a values-based content strategy

Stop looking for the magic copy writing formula or the perfect email marketing swipe file to copy and paste! YOU are the magic formula. Only you know how to connect with your ideal clients because you are uniquely you!

read more
How Instagram Search Works

How Instagram Search Works

So How Does Instagram Search Work? Instagram search works by finding content based on your search term - taking into account pages, post content, locations - your results will vary from another person as Instagram uses an algorithm that takes into account your own...

read more